Search Readiness Assessment
Eleven questions. A candid read on where your executive search really stands, and the one thing to fix first.
Our Framework
The Four Stages of an Executive Search
Every executive search moves through the same four stages, in order: Launch, Source, Recruit, Select. Each stage has a gate, a set of conditions that must be true before the next stage can succeed. Searches rarely fail at the stage where the trouble shows. They fail because an earlier gate was never cleared. Blue Rock Human Capital uses this framework to place every incoming search, and the assessment above applies it to your answers.
Launch
Define the role and align the people who decide.
- A written scorecard: the five to seven outcomes the leader must own by month 12
- Every stakeholder with a vote or a veto describes the same ideal candidate
- Compensation benchmarked against the current market
- A named owner and a real in-seat date
Source
Map the market, including the people who are not looking.
- A researched list of the 20 to 40 people who could do the job
- Where each one works today, and what might move them
- A plan to approach them, confidentially when needed
Recruit
Turn names into candidates who want the job.
- A two-sentence story for why a high performer would leave a good job for this one
- Every stakeholder tells the same story
- A process fast enough to keep strong candidates engaged
Select
Assess finalists and close the hire.
- Finalists assessed against the scorecard, not against each other
- One clear final decision-maker
- Internal and external candidates in the same process
- An offer and counter-offer plan ready before it is needed
Timeline Benchmarks
How Long an Executive Search Actually Takes
Time to seat is arithmetic, not optimism. Count backward from the date the new leader must be at the desk.
| Stage and phase | Typical duration |
|---|---|
| Launch: scorecard, stakeholder alignment, compensation benchmark | 1 to 2 weeks |
| C-suite search in private equity, kickoff to signed offer | 63 days avg. |
| C-suite search in higher education, kickoff to signed offer | 67 days avg. |
| C-suite search at a Fortune company, kickoff to signed offer | 75 days avg. |
| CEO search, kickoff to signed offer | 90 to 120 days |
| Executive notice period after the offer is signed | 2 to 6 weeks |
| Typical first day in seat, from Launch | 3 to 6 months |
Common Questions
Executive Search Questions, Answered
How long does an executive search take?
On average, a retained C-suite search takes about 63 days from kickoff to signed offer in private equity, 67 days in higher education, and 75 days at large corporations. CEO searches take 90 to 120 days. With a week or two of preparation up front and a notice period of 2 to 6 weeks, most new leaders are in the seat about 3 to 6 months after the search begins.
What are the stages of an executive search?
Launch, Source, Recruit, and Select. Launch defines the role and aligns the decision-makers. Source maps the market, including executives who are not looking. Recruit turns names into interested candidates. Select assesses finalists and closes the hire. Each stage depends on the one before it, so a search that skips Launch work usually stalls at Select.
What is a search scorecard, and how is it different from a job description?
A job description lists duties and reporting lines. A scorecard defines what success looks like at month 12: the five to seven outcomes the new leader must own, agreed in writing by everyone who will judge them. Candidates at the executive level can tell which document they are being recruited against, and it changes who says yes.
Why do executive searches fail?
Most failed searches break at the front end rather than in the candidate pool. The recurring causes are an undefined role, stakeholders who never reconciled their ideal profiles, compensation that was never benchmarked, a search that only reached people already looking, and no clear reason a high performer would leave a good job for this one.
How is a confidential executive search run?
Without a public posting. The search uses a code name, approaches a researched list of candidates one at a time, controls references, and limits who inside the organization knows. When an incumbent is still in the seat, a communication plan is agreed before the first candidate call. Retained search is the only workable model for confidential searches.
What should a company know before hiring its first CHRO?
Decide the scope first. A first CHRO is usually expected to be both a strategic partner to the CEO and the operator of the HR function, and candidates are strong at one more often than both. Write down which outcomes matter at month 12, benchmark pay against that scope, and make sure the CEO and the board agree on it before the search opens.
What is the difference between retained and contingency search?
Contingency recruiters are paid on placement and optimize for speed of submission from the actively looking market. Retained search is paid to run a defined process and optimizes for quality of hire across the whole market, including executives who are not looking. At senior levels, the difference is usually the hire itself, and retained is the only workable model for confidential searches.
Should an internal candidate go through the same executive search process?
Yes. A serious internal candidate should be assessed in the same process, against the same scorecard, as the external market. Running them outside it loses them if they are passed over and undermines the external hire's mandate if they win.
How soon should compensation be benchmarked in a search?
Before the search opens, during Launch. Benchmarking takes a week or two. Discovering a compensation gap at the recruiting or offer stage is the most expensive point at which to find it. Compensation should never be discovered 65 days into a search, because you run the risk of losing not only the candidate going to offer, but the runner-up as well.
Ready to Find Your Next Great Leader?
Most searches begin with a 30-minute call. No pitch. Just clarity on fit and timeline.